Posts Tagged ‘War’

Justified or not; Israel

I firmly believe that, as with many things in life, there’s no clear-cut right or wrong in the Israel/Palestine conflict — sadly various mythologies that are taken as literal truth by the various sides in the conflict promise the territory in question to groups who appear not to be able to live together.

The original plans were ill-thought-through but at least allowed areas of land with majority Muslim populations to remain outside of Jewish control and vice versa. Unfortunately attacks from neighbouring countries put paid to that plan and left Israel in control of the west bank of the river Jordan and the Gaza Strip.

The US moved from being strongly against the League of Nations plan to, these days, providing much of Israel’s military capability and being the only Security Council country that does not regularly criticise Israel’s actions.

But this ridiculously quick summary of the history of modern Israel is nowhere near enough and I strongly recommend anyone who doesn’t know the full story reads it on Wikipedia or similar.

From the Telegraph website today:

With Palestinian medics saying the death toll had risen to more than 780, two Hamas rockets hit the Israeli town of Ashkelon.

It’s madness, it really is. You tickle a tiger often enough and it’s going to bite; now if the tiger has bitten the last thing you do is continue to tickle — you hope it speaks and you try and reason with it and apologise for your stupidity.

Hamas may not like Israel and may not believe it ought to exist, but the way to resolve this situation (not just the current crisis) is to engage — nothing, at all, will be achieved by murder and the Israelis deserve kudos for their patience with Hamas thus far.

, , , , , ,

No Comments


Constitution or Policies?

On Friday I started a new job. I won’t say much about my work, as I didn’t before because of the trouble people seem to get into when they blog about their place of work. Saying that, though, I’ve never felt there’s been much bad to say about my employer but hey ho.

Anyway, the reason I told you that is because it now means that rather than driving 15 minutes along the A27 I need to drive for nearer 1 hour 15 minutes including a stretch of the M25 — a round trip of around 90 miles. On Friday too, I started car sharing to reduce some of that burden, petrol etc. (note no spurious mention of the environment). And today was the first journey with only one of the sharers.

I am painfully aware that I can turn on speech/lecture mode very easily and I make serious efforts not to initiate or prolong political conversations. So it was reassuring today that the conversation on the way home was about things that I think ought to concern young, male 20-somethings:

  • House prices
  • The tax we pay for social sponges
  • The war in Iraq vs. the lack of war in Zimbabwe
  • The general wetting-down of England
  • The worrying increase in religious belief

If the journey had lasted longer, I would expect it to move to the state of the BBC, how Channel 4 are so much better at programming, the worrying rise in uncontrolled internal movement in the EU.

And it turns out that us right-wingers are far more compassionate than the so-called lefty do-gooders. While we believe in Grammar schools which help people achieve regardless of social backgrounds, while we believe that social housing is a gift to the lazy and relatively scant help to the hard-working, while we believe that government money would be better spent (or not raised through taxes) on services that people need rather than on yet another campaign to stop people hurting themselves with alcohol (it’s their body for Christ’s sake), while we believe in free trade with poorer countries not spurious Fair Trade, and while we believe in helping those in genuine need (like the victims of 2005′s Tsunami)… While we believe those things, the left do not.

The Left believes that Fair Trade (helping a few farmers get a non-market driven — and still low — price for their product) is the answer to global poverty. It believes that we should give aid to Darfur rather than tanks to stop the genocide; It believes that the government should look after each individual even down to the nitty-gritty of their lives; And it believes that any different lifestyle that does not result in dreadlocks or prayer (or both) is to be stamped out by the state.

So when the UK Independence Party is laughed at by the BBC (and for obvious, and understandable, reasons), let’s remember that they are the ones who are against Social Housing being FORCED on developers (building on their own private land remember), they are the ones against high taxation and they are the ones who recognise genuine fairness.

When I joined the Conservatives in 1996, it was because I could see that their ideology was based in fairness, merit and (increasingly at the time, though completely thankfully now) genuine equal rights. I still believe that is what the membership believes in and, sadly, UKIP are completely ineffectual at every level, so I remain a Conservative.

But this is a call to those who believe in ideology and fairness: stop using politics as a method of achieving power, and start using it as a tool to convince people of your ideology and stand for election on principles.

, , , , , , , ,

4 Comments


A Bright Speech

Sam Harris is another in the growing number among us humans who believes that religion per se is dangerous. Listen to what he has to say:

If you agree, or even if you just know there’s no reason to believe in God, consider signing up (for free) as a Bright and spreading the 21st Century’s Enlightenment.

, , , , , , , , , , ,

14 Comments


Peace

Without the usual, “Why can’t we all just live in peace” naivete:

, , , , , , , , , ,

2 Comments


Iraq and Gaza

The Iraq war continues to claim lives and we continue to be there. Some people claim that those two facts are related.

But the Gaza Strip is, according to media reports, beginning to suffer attacks from Islamofacists not least an attack recently against a UN school. Since Alan Johnston was kidnapped, it is said, foreigners have been travelling into Gaza less and the area generally feels less safe. I don’t want to comment on the subjective nature of this assessment, but it makes a point anyway.

Since Israel pulled out of Gaza and let the Palestinians manage their own security, security for Palestianians has worsened. This is not an argument for occupation — far from it — but should we (the US and Britain) take the blame for the violence in Iraq when it is Islamofacists who are carrying out the attacks (and the vast majority against other Iraqis, not the Allied troops)?

Though the war was started in Iraq on false pretenses, and though what we did was clearly wrong, would it not now be doubly wrong to pull out of Iraq and hope it gets better? Though the war was started (at least according to the US) as part of the war on terror, isn’t it now only too true that we are fighting Al Qaeda (as well as an arrogant Iran) here? Isn’t there a case for suggesting that pulling out of Iraq would turn Iraq into the Afghanistan that was? A country full of terrorist training grounds and supported (by inaction and impotence) by the Iraqi government?

, ,

1 Comment


North Korea

The impact of the oil-folly in Iraq is still expanding. North Korea’s nuclear test is a clear sign to the rest of the world that the UN is impotent and that the US has made pre-emptive miltary action a non-option.

, ,

4 Comments


Not home, not yet

A colleague has posted the following video to YouTube:

That video calls for the return of Britain’s troops from Afghanistan. I cannot condone this.

Whether we think the Iraq war was right or wrong, we’re there now and we must stay and finish the job. But almost no-one thought then, or thinks now, that the Afghanistan war was wrong. The explosion of two ancient Hindu Buddhist statues touched me in a way that I cannot quite get over to you. That was the most widely advertised example of the Taliban’s absolutely, completely inhumane regime. It is not only right that we are in Afghanistan — it is morally necessary that we stay and that we stop this country from being a failed state.

Somalia, sadly, is on its way to a similar fate (after anarchy-cum-libertarianism nearly brought an ideal state into being). If we do not save Afghanistan now, then we must recognise that Somalia will be just as condemned by that failure.

4 Comments


Oh no

I’ve not read the full story, but it appears North Korea are publicly acknowledging their nuclear ambitions:

North Korea to perform nuclear test.

7 Comments


Public opinion by the BBC

As J0nz pointed out, Hezbollah and Israel are thought of very differently by Britons than by the BBC… Have Your Say.

, , ,

No Comments


Israel condemned but…

The impractical but vocal old-European nations were among the first to shout foul about Israel’s recent attempts to defend itself but it is Italy, not France or Germany, that is providing the majority of troops to the Lebanon.

France, according to the last figures I saw, are contributing 200 troops, Bangladesh (commendably) 1,000 and Italy 3,000. For obvious reasons Britain and the US are unable to commit troops.

But surely, as the second most powerful miltary power in Europe, France should be contributing at least as many troops as the coalition-of-the-willing-Italy. Israel, I am sure, would have happily allowed Hezbollah to be disarmed by third parties with no direct benefit. Israel, by implication then, would have been happy for the UN to stop terrorists attacking it and kidnapping its soldiers.

But the UN, despite all the obvious need, is again shown to be toothless. Were I a terrorist in the Middle East watching on at this, I would be more concerned about the serious efforts of Israel, Britain, Italy and the US than I would be of the rest of the world combined. The UN, if it did its job, could stop Britain, Israel and the US from appearing to be bullies in a world full of real bullies (Hezbollah, Hamas and Al Qaeda).

So, France, put your money where your mouth is and help Israel and the Lebanon avoid further anti-state terrorist activity.

, ,

4 Comments



SetPageWidth